As we dive into October, it's the perfect time to get cozy with delicious cheeses, and we can't stop raving about Trader Joe's Unexpected Cheddar Cheese. This 7-time award-winning cheese has stolen hearts and taste buds alike. It's so adored that it earned a spot in the Trader Joe's Product Hall of Fame!
First introduced in 2011, this year-round favorite marries the boldness of aged cheddar with Italian parmesan's rich, nutty flavor. We first tried it during a casual cheese-tasting night, and let's say we seriously want to devour the entire block!
So, what makes this cheese so "unexpected"?
Imagine taking a bite of something that looks and tastes like aged cheddar. You start with that familiar sharpness, but then the fun begins! The smooth creaminess shifts to a tangy flavor with a slightly crumbly texture, and as the cheese melts in your mouth, the true "unexpected" aspect of Trader Joe's Unexpected Cheddar sets in. While the first bite aligns with the cheddar we know and love, it evolves further—revealing hints of salt crystals and a taste reminiscent of aged Parmesan - a delightful journey of flavor and texture.
Now, let's talk about versatility!
The Unexpected Cheddar shines in various settings—perfect for charcuterie boards, enriching creamy macaroni and cheese, elevating a classic grilled cheese sandwich, or enhancing salads. You can even enjoy it on its own, maybe with a glass of your favorite wine. It's fancy enough to impress your foodie friends but still approachable for anyone who might shy away from stronger cheeses.
Whether hosting a gathering or enjoying a quiet night in, Unexpected Cheddar is a star addition to any charcuterie board. Imagine a beautiful platter filled with nuts, olives, fruits, and generous chunks of this delightful cheese. Its crumbly texture can pose a little challenge when slicing it into perfect squares, but we think that adds to its charm. We promise even those irregular chunks will taste heavenly when enjoyed with your favorite accompaniments.
Now's the perfect time if you have yet to indulge in Trader Joe's Unexpected Cheddar Cheese! And there's no better way to enjoy this fan-favorite cheese than on a beautifully curated charcuterie board from Sara's Boxes & Boards. Don't wait—place your order today and treat yourself and your loved ones to a charcuterie experience like no other!
